eddobloggo® - Commentary Archive

10/26/14 Undecided?
9/28/14 Yelling "BANG!"
8/22/14 Laboring under a delusion.  
8/3/14 No Second Amendment protection.....
7/1/14 Put a sock in it!
6/8/14 Moonwalking then and now.
5/11/14 The last anti-American professor's voice.
4/4/14 April Fools
3/17/14 Cold War or Cold Feet?
3/7/14 None is righteous...
2/24/14 "If even ONE life..."
2/13/14 "...the reality of the world we live in."
2/1/14 Some good news about heart attacks.
1/26/14 "No place" for propaganda.
1/19/14 What difference has she ever made?
1/12/14 Dept. of Labor: "We Can Help"
1/5/14 Perhaps she'll die...
* 2013 Commentary Archive
* eddo's Antique Trunk Projects


Site Map

XML Sitemap

   Defending the right to rant!  








Ed Donath is eddobloggo...Conservative Commentary Columnist


eddobloggo® - The logo for Conservative Commentary by Ed Donath -"Defending the right to rant!"

Defending the right to rant!


Conservative Commentary

 by Ed Donath



What you DON'T see in the Eric Garner arrest video. click here to subscribe to the eddobloggo RSS feed 

NYPD PatrolcarAs a boomer-kid during the Fifties and Sixties I spent all day every day on the street in Brooklyn. There were countless times when I witnessed NYPD officers making arrests. Later, after two summers of taxi driving followed by several years as a territorial salesman in the greater New York area, I had seen plenty of collars-in-progress.


To my recollection, arresting officers' pistols were un-holstered at some point during every arrest. Often, both the cop's gun and nightstick were used to seal the deal. As such, suspects occasionally received blows about the legs or head from the arresting officer's billy club. The cop's target for the sweet spot of his club depended upon the egregiousness of a particular perp's lack of cooperation. As a result of such common knowledge, the threat of a “wooden shampoo” was effectively issued by cops on the beat, compelling loiterers and hooligans to “move along” quickly.


An argument could be made that such tactics constituted excessive force. However, during the era that preceded PC Mania and when “minority” arrests were exactly that, the police in New York City were never accused of abridging anyone's civil rights let alone of racism. Any cop would have made the counter argument that the taxpayers had equipped him with a gun and a nightstick for his own protection and for the protection of the citizenry and it would be a breach of promise not to use the tools of the trade as he was trained.


How do you subdue a guy that size without using any weapons?

How would you subdue a man this size without using any weapons? 

Would you quit arresting him if he says: "I can't breathe?"


In the smart phone video-recorded arrest of Eric Garner in Staten Island, which you certainly have viewed at least once by now, there are no weapons of any kind visible.


That a very large man who was clearly resisting arrest was quickly subdued without even the threat of deadly force is a testament to the reserve of the arresting officers. Furthermore, not one punch was thrown and no disparaging remarks were made by the cops.


If I'm a grand juror, after viewing that video I would need to be provided with more substantial evidence than was recorded by the eyewitness's smart phone in order to indict Officer Pantaleo on any homicide-related charge – especially since Mr. Garner remained alive during the entire arrest process, being pronounced dead some time later after being taken by ambulance to a local hospital.


Which brings us to the now-famous phrase “I can't breathe!” repeatedly uttered by Eric Garner from the moment his subdued body hit the sidewalk.


Like a man in desperate need of the Heimlich Maneuver due to a chunk of food blocking his windpipe, any plea for help by a choking perp would have to be acted out in pantomime for the utter inability to speak. That is not to say that Garner, an over-weight asthmatic smoker was not having difficulty breathing as the cops put pressure on him, but it is easy to agree with anyone who believes that resisting arrest could or perhaps should be an uncomfortable physical experience.


It is also a fact – to which I have been a witness on many occasions – that people being manhandled by police are very likely to claim that they are in pain, have broken bones and/or cannot breathe. Whether their injuries are real or faked, playing to the crowd makes suspects believe they will have an advantage in court or in a later civil suit against the city.


Exhale Eric Holder, Al Sharpton, Barack Obama et al.  You have the right to remain silent but, if you choose to speak, anything you say can and will be held against you.


eddbloggo home 









Please provide your name (or screen name) and geographical location.





 YOUR COMMENTS    (subject to editing for clarity and/or profanity)

Sorry Ed, I have COPD and there have been several times when I have thought I can't breath when in fact I was breathing but NOT WELL and very raggedly. I could still utter words though gasping. I also have congestive heart failure so restricted breathing could put a heck of a strain on my heart. Just because he could say "I can't breath" DOESN'T mean he could. He still could have been in respiratory distress and in need of IMMEDIATE emergency assistance. I am NOT saying the officer did any5thing wrong but understand thinking that because this man could say "I can't breath" doesn't mean he was NOT IN AN EMERGENCY SITUATION.


Ed I missed your rants, were you gone for awhile? this is the first one I have gotten for a long time.



Great Falls, MT

[Unfortunately, Eric Garner was more concerned with staying out of jail than staying out of the cemetery. As for my laying low this year, my gut said that anything I would point about your Dear Leader and the Obamunsts would not have made most folks despise them any less going into the important midterm elections.  Reruns have been my way of saying: "I told you so." -- and proving it -ED]

Great to see you back! Good rant eddo. Loss of life is always regretable...however, if you don't want consequences enforced, behave yourself. Garner knew his medical condition, the officers did not.


New Columbia, PA

Good to see you back eddo. I, for one, would welcome back the 50's and 60's ways of enforcing laws.

Montgomery, AL

It has taken me a few days to try and find a way to formulate a cogent comment. Unable to do so, this comment might not cut it, OK?

After almost 30 years of being a sheriff and marshal, I am of the opinion that 99% of the population in this country has no idea what cops see - and do - on a daily basis.

That being said, the Left Wing Liberal loons will almost surely be excited when the street cops STOP being proactive for fear of getting in trouble with their superiors. Like the man said, a democracy is the prelude to socialism...



The Wild, Wild West.

[It not only "cuts it" but it's cogent, as well. -ED]

BorMar Technologies:


Cross-linked Websites:


Adopt a pet!

e-Business Cards

Enginneering Services, CD Business Cards and more from BorMar!

 Engineering Services

     << Hugmomma

 << Matlock

     << Nutmegger


It's AXL!


AXL the German Shepherd Wonder Dog is eddobloggo's best friend!


© Copyright Ed Donath/eddobloggo®

"Defending the right to rant!"


All rights reserved worldwide.

For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places. - Ephesians 6:12