eddobloggo®

"Defending the right to rant!"""

"There's a fine line between liberalism and insanity. I'm here to keep you from crossing

that line and to bring you back if you cross it."

Commentary Archive

3/5/10 Get ACLU! (Taliban Lawyers do)
2/28/10 A Monumental Government Land Grab
2/24/10 The Chai Party
2/21/10 Don't confuse us with those other extremists.
2/19/10 Karl Rove helps set the left's Tea Party trap.
2/14/10 corruption.guv

2/11/10

The sound of one hand clapping.

2/7/10

Have a seat and some tea.

1/31/10

The Obama Accelerator Pedal Recall

1/29/10

The State of the Union in 200 words or less.

1/24/10

OnStar call replay call you'll never hear...

1/20/10

NJ, VA, MA and a near-miss in NY

1/17/10

Dealing with the Car Czar...

1/15/10

What can YOU say?

1/10/10

"Systemic Failure" = Obama Failure

1/3/10

Some Good News About Heart Attacks

1/1/10

Homeland Security picture is out of focus.

*

2009 Commentary Archive

*

2008 Commentary Archive

XML Sitemap

 

 


Get your website found!

Get your website found! - e-finders - Get your blog found!

SEO Specialists

 

BorMarEnginneering Services, CD Business Cards and more from BorMar!Technologies

CD Business Cards & More

 Engineering Services


 

Conservative Commentary

by Ed Donath

----------------------------

© Copyright Ed Donath March 9, 2010

All rights reserved worldwide.

>> Bookmark eddobloggo®

eddobloggo - Ed Donath Conservative Blog

 

 

eddobloggo logo

 

The more it changes.

click here to subscribe to the eddobloggo RSS feed

RSS feed

Celebrating the six-month anniversary of the six-months-into-it Obama health care overhaul (make that health care reform...no, better make that insurance reform...no, better make it insurance overhaul) speech.


The president's speech to a joint session of Congress Wednesday evening 9/9/09 was full of Obamacare promises.  Mostly they were the oft-repeated, yet-to-be clarified claims that have remained so loosely defined, by design, to allow for more palatable phraseology as the latest poll results and logical arguments may demand.

 

But his "impassioned" teleprompter address was also laced with threats.  The threats, in the form of ultimatums, were issued to both conservative and progressive opponents of the various elements of the bill.  In so many words the president repeated that he is not about to take "no" for an answer and that "not another year" will be allowed to pass before some form -- apparently any form -- of his initiative is signed into law.

 

Whereas liberals and neo-lib progressives were somewhat inspired, if not placated, by the president's crocodile tears during the reading of a posthumous letter from Teddy Kennedy, Conservatives were offered no consolation prize.  Obama's repeated admonitions to support his plan or get out of the way when the steamroller shows up summed up his willingness to compromise.

 

"You lie!" says Rep. Joe Wilson to Obama's claim that his socialized medicine program will NOT cover illegal aliens.So incendiary and disingenuous were many of the president's comments that an otherwise soft-spoken veteran congressman from South Carolina, Rep. Joe Wilson, was unable to stifle a loud cry of "You lie!" when Obama denied that universal coverage would be extended to so-called undocumented immigrants.

 

Most cogently stated are Rep. Michele Bachmann's rebuttal comments on Obama's speech. "Divisive", "partisan", "dismissive" and "angry" are among the words she uses to describe the tone of his desperate pitch.

 

Ironically, Obama's most incredible promise, as well as his most significant threat, were both stated within a short three-sentence snippet from his typically lengthy rant:

 

"I will not sign a plan that adds one dime to our deficits -- either now or in the future. Period.  And to prove that I’m serious there will be a provision in this plan that requires us to come forward with more spending cuts if the savings we promised don’t materialize."

 

The pie-in-the-sky promise inherent in this statement has already been debunked by the Congressional Budget Office.  Many critics point to the relatively uncomplicated, insignificant Cash for Clunkers program that ended up costing the taxpayers more than three times the originally estimated price tag.  They also reference the ineffectiveness of the stimulus program and unemployment under-estimates as reasons to question this administration's ability to predict the results of anything.

 

Since the promise part of the statement might only be keep-able by enacting huge spending cuts -- most likely in combination with tax increases -- if those cuts were limited only to health care-oriented spending, decreased quality of care, rationing and the death panels that have been a large part of the plan's criticism would eventually come to pass.

 

But the term "spending cuts" is not defined and so it is likely that Obama would cut spending in non-socialistic areas before any others.  Our national defense is most likely, therefore, to be compromised -- a most sobering thought on this anniversary of al Qaida's attack on the United States of America.

Just as the promises and threats are summed up in three short sentences of the president's speech, the lies and truth of Obamacare are condensed into another snippet:

 

"These are the facts. Nobody disputes them. We know we must reform this system. The question is how."

 

Each of the alleged facts are, of course, highly disputable.  That is precisely why there has been so much and such a heated protest of this reform for reform's sake; reform for the sake of one man's legacy.

 

Six truthful words were spoken during the 48 minutes of the president's address.  Four by the president: "The question is how." and two by Congressman Wilson: "You lie!"


Next up, more definitive leadership as your president dedicates himself to creating jobs in addition to the numerous jobs that shrinking the insurance industry's participation in health care are supposed to help create but which you'll have to wait at least four years to find out if any of it works...


eddobloggo home/archive

 

SCROLL DOWN TO ADD COMMENTS...

 

 

 

ADD YOUR COMMENTS.... Please provide your name (or screen name) and geographical location.

  Click here to send comments if you experience difficulty with this form or to sign up for the eddobloggo® e-mail list.

 


Reader Comments:

Comments may be edited for clarity and/or profanity.


Excellent analysis Ed.

 

richiephx

Phoenix, AZ Arizona Republic

[There's three words I like to hear.  Thanks. -ED]


Well, loosely defined except for the thousand page document of details that you haven't bothered to look up.

What's loosely defined is why Republicans oppose it so vehemently. The reasons they've given, "Death panels! Fascism!" etc have been such baloney, they're the ones leaving the big question mark. Of course, considering their close ties to the insurance industry MIGHT provide a clue.

And what is tragic is that so many working people who would benefit from this but are unfortunately under the sway of the gop or their media shills and are loudly opposing a thing that would benefit them greatly over the long term.

 

Iowadad

Des Moines, IA Register

['Loosely defined' are the two words you picked out of my commentary for this overpriced hoax perpetration. They fit nicely even when uttered by a lefty. -ED]


Thank you for the analysis. I didn't watch because I'm tired of watching the campaigning. It sounds like he is losing it, and fails to realize that he may not have as much power as he thinks he does.

 

rainbowed

Great Falls, MT Tribune


obama came off as a jimmy carter in training, old bitter and divisive. How he or his handlers thought that speech would help his numbers or the cause is beyond me. Joe Wilson had bad timing but was on point...

 

...Crisis crisis crisis, the theme of the obama failure. "step over this line" ...back up a few steps.... "step over this line" .... infinitum ad nauseum. He is a school yard bully , but the brave are calling his bluffs.

 

deserttrek

Palm Springs, CA Desert Sun


For whatever it's worth, Bill O'Reilly says that by the end of Obama's first year, America will be broke. But don't quote me on that!

 

BuffTheReformer

Des Moines, IA Register

[You mean we're not broke yet? -ED]


"I will not sign a plan that adds one dime to our deficits -- either now or in the future."

The choice of the word "deficits" is most interesting. Why did he not say "debt." Therein lies the deceit. The annual deficits can continue at $1.5-$2 trillion annually. The debt continues to become less manageable. The gulls don't understand the deceit. Never will...

 

...Whenever dear leader reads a speech, my mind's eye always sees something resembling a union hall on the southside of Chicago with 90-100 people in the audience. It's hard to separate the propaganda from the lies. The threats are bare.

If he is successful in seizing the "medical services industry," I would favor forcing the Congress and bureaucracy into the system, especially since government jobs now pay more when compared to private sector jobs. The higher paid government employees and retirees will be more able to pay the increased costs.

How is that hopey, changey thingy doing, now?

 

GreyCaravel

Montgomery, AL Advertiser


GREY- you are wrong...the "gulls" as you call them understand things very well and now so do we. They prefer changing our government, devaluing our money, and getting us into a socialist "style government" just to stay in power. The 2 upcoming governors elections (in obama won states) have the demos behind by a wide margin...change is a coming my friends. Just wish it were the "3rd party" coming into power.

 

nobama4me

Montgomery, AL Advertiser


Wow! I have been waiting for this and in the old days of being a cop we called them, "Who-me's." When we wanted to question some skel and yelled at him/her they would reply as, "Who Me?" This speech was no more than a convoluted and feeble attempt... things we have already heard. Does struggling with the truth strike a bell here??

 

boned

Great Falls, MT Tribune


Hmmm - seems to me I remember the Republicans passing a huge increase in spending for Medicare - the drug benefit that Bush pushed through.

Odd, though, what I don't remember is the level of hysteria from Republicans. Help me out eddo, did you call it an overpriced hoax perpretation at the time? Were the tea baggers in the streets packing iron when the Prez came to talk to them? Did a Dem shout that Dubya was a liar during one of his speeches? ...

 

Craig51

Des Moines, IA Register

[As for Congressional decorum, the Dems routinely roared and booed GWB. Harry Reid even called him a "liar and a loser" and never apologized. So why the double standard now?  The vast majority of tea-partiers have a single, non-partisan message -- that anything the government runs is wasteful and inefficient and, therefore, overspent. "Spend less, do more" should be the simple Wal-Mart-like slogan and, if it were organized like you lefties claim it is, it would be a lot slicker and better branded than it is.  If every heat-packing con and libertarian you see at the town halls and in the streets had voted for McCain, the Dear Leader would be running for Senate again on Rezko's, ACORN's and the thug unions' money. -ED]


Ed, I have recently started to think that perhaps we (the non radicals) should let the left do what they want. Let them destroy and mess everything up that they want  because if we stop them now it will be just another four years of how we stole the election, more of the "well republicans block everything we tried to do" They will even claim we are responsible for Obama's fall(which is coming) There will be NOTHING GAINED. They will spin everything around to fit their needs. There fore I am starting to think let them go....Like a big fish ...give them a lot of line then set the hook. If we don't they will blame all on us.... My point is liberals cant see anything because of the rose tinted glasses so let them go and they have NOBODY to blame but them selves...

 

Rocco0607

Montana

[I'd rather run the risks you suggest and curtail the debacle to the greatest extent possible.  Besides, do you really think they'll hate you any less after two Obama terms? If he can't dictate his way into three terms it'll still be Bush's fault. -ED]


I heard today another Congressman walked out before the speech was finished. I can't remember his name but I give him kudos also.  AS usual very well put Ed. Thanks again.

 

Grandpa2743

Lansing, MI State Journal


You see, if anyone opposes Obama, they are a fear monger, but if you don't get on board with his plan, the result will be catastrophic. There are 46 million uninsured in America, 12 million of those are illegal aliens and 20 million of those choose not to buy insurance, but could afford it. That leaves 14 million uninsured who want insurance. That is less than 5 percent of the population. For 5 percent of the population, we are willing to dismantle the current healthcare system and surrender our liberty to the government. I don't think so.

 

mightyright

Great Falls, MT Tribune


Wilson had him pegged. He's just a mean green fibbin' machine.

 

BilBala2

Lansing, MI State Journal


This is the second effort by the Dems to reform health care. The Rebubs have made NO concerted effort to solve the failed system of health care, and in fact have done everything possible to maintain the corrupt stranglehold the corporations have on us. Looking at how many dems also are resisting single payer, it is apparent that both parties are once again representing the same elite controllers - there is not a dimes worth of difference between them. It is ridiculous to argue that one party is at fault when both are equally representing the same corporate masters. We saw with the TARP funding that representatives can receive single-message mail from 99% of the population and still vote against them. Health reform is a lost cause under this government structure.

 

Non-Sheeple

Newark, DE

[The only corrupt stranglehold that matters right now is the one the Dear Leader and his kommie kongress have us in.  Socialism is proven to be a failed system and that's where he wants to take us.  First things first. -ED]


The only thing more sad than a congress bent on passing legislation americans DO NOT WANT is these liberal peons "swallowing" any/everything he says. Bush they put in a box...obama they give oral to pretty much sums them/him up. He is...and always will be classified as the MOST corrupt president we have ever had. Corn husker deal....LA purchase, having the likes of VAN JONES in the white house. Boy oh boy what the left will swallow for the master. By the way...is Florida still exempt from this tax dear leader?

 

nobama4me

Montgomery, AL Advertiser


The people are realizing this is about control, not healthcare. But is it too late? By the way, Have you heard about the new "Coffee Party" billed as a new alternative to the Tea Party? Just happens to be run by Annabel Park, an Obama campaign operative who was key in his election. There is such fear of the Tea Party that they continue trying to hijack and dilute it.

 

Moralmoxie

Palm Springs, CA Desert Sun

[How did  they ever come up with that one? click here -ED]


The president doesn't care about what the American people are saying or how they feel about health care. He believes his legacy is riding on health care and he will not take no for an answer. He knows he doesn't have the super majority in the senate so is bent on reconciliation as the means to ram it through. He finds a way to intimidate freshman congressmen who may be opposed to health care by allegedly helping force Congressman Massa out of office. (The message being clear - vote my way or else). Interesting to see your site is under review by the editors. Apparently those who disagree with the president and the press can be silenced by not printing their words of disagreement.

 

oldprofessor

Rochester, NY Democrat&Chronicle


I thought the Democrat party was supposed to be "Pro-Choice." What a joke! (A Bad Joke) Where is the argument for freedom of choice with regards to this piece of Cr@) known affectionately as Obamacare? They don't believe in choice. In fact, they don't believe in freedom in any of its manifestations. This pretender in the White House is a disaster--in every way possible. Even most 2nd graders could tell him the measures needed to turn around this wrecked economy... and actually get Americans back to work. But, he and his cohorts don't care about that. They ignore the obvious and even pretend that they are governing with the consent of the people... His presidency has failed. Thank God.

 

SteelCloud

Montgomery, AL Advertiser


It's a celebration every day eddo. I am always looking forward to what the daily celebration is about but then...that is what the media is there for.

 

Artyman1

Des Moines, IA Register

[The media celebration is about everything getting bigger everyday...

Bad News: government, the deficit, the number of jobless, spending, Obama's head, the lies. Good News: anti-left poll numbers. -ED]


 

 Read eddobloggo® here...                                                                                                                                           

Burlington, VT Free Press Greenville, SC News Palm Springs, CA Desert Sun Salinas, CA The Californian Wausau, WI Daily Herald
Cincinnati, OH Enquirer Indianapolis, IN Star Phoenix, AZ Arizona Republic Springfield, MO News-Leader White Plains, NY Journal News
Des Moines, IA Register Lansing, MI State Journal Poughkeepsie, NY Journal St. Cloud, MN Times Wilmington, DE News Journal
Great Falls, MT Tribune Mansfield, OH News Journal Rochester, NY Democrat&Chronicle Staunton, VA News Leader

Read Ed 
Donath Commentary at Townhall Blogs

Green Bay, WI PressGazette Montgomery, AL Advertiser Salem, OR Statesman-Journal Tallahassee, FL Democrat
 

 

Axl the Wonderdog!

 

who is the blogwatchdog?